Li Shimin, an eternal monarch, why did he insist on killing Dan Xiong Xin and even Xu Maogong couldn't save him?

Why did the eternal monarch Li Shimin insist on killing Dan Xiong Xin? Even Xu couldn't save Sui and Tang Dynasties. Because of Yang Guang's tyranny, the heroes united. At that time in Athens, Dan Xiong Xin was definitely a role to be reckoned with. He is not only good at martial arts, but also has good results in leading troops to fight.

Besides being good at martial arts and fighting, Dan Xiong Xin is also praised by the world for treating people. As a "chivalrous man", as early as Erxianzhuang, Dan Xiong Xin not only bullied the weak, but also often robbed the rich to help the poor. The people who benefited from him are ordinary people, and we are familiar with General Qin Qiong and Qin Qiong, who are embarrassed to sell their mounts. When Dan Xiong Xin found out, he even helped the poor through giving money to each other.

Besides, Shi Biao also got his help when he was in trouble. Dan Xiong Xin is a very brave man. From the story of 46 famous friends in Erxianzhuang, we can see his character at that time, so his contacts are quite wide.

In 6 13 AD, Zhai Rang rebelled against the Sui Dynasty in Wagangzhai. Dan Xiong Xin defected with his good friend Xu Shiqi and started his military career. Later, Wagangzhai was defeated by the king, and many people of insight in Wagangzhai defected, even his old friend Xu Shiqi defected. But after the defeat, Dan went to Dan. Why didn't he surrender to King He, knowing that King was not a democratic leader, but stubbornly did not conform to the times and did not abandon the dark side? Why? To get to the bottom of it, we have to start with their parents.

Dan Xiong Xin's grandfather is very famous. He used to be a general in the Northern Zhou Dynasty and helped unify the North. Seeing his outstanding military exploits, Yu named him a general to protect the country and stationed in Dongchang.

Dan Xiong Xin's grandfather had a son named Shan Yu. He was tall and strong, and he was good at martial arts. When he grew up, he inherited his father's title and was still stationed in Dongchang. In 58 1 year, Tang Yuan, a general of Sui Dynasty, was ordered to attack Dongchang. Shan Yu and Tang Yuan fought a bloody battle for seven days and seven nights, and their fighting capacity was greatly reduced. Unfortunately, the strength is very different. Tang gaozu finally breached the city gate, captured Shan Yu alive, and was killed by Shang Yuan, losing face.

The single family fled to Luzhou in a hurry, and from then on, they built a manor, bought fields and settled in Erxian Village. However, the feud between Shan and Li did not end there.

After the Sui Dynasty unified the north and the south, Tang Gaozu was named the magistrate of Taiyuan. On his way to office, he was hunted by Yuwen Shu. Tang Gaozu, with his amazing swordsmanship and tenacious resistance of accompanying soldiers, barely resisted the attack. But Yuwen Shu has been looking for an excellent opportunity to kill Tang Gaozu to prevent him from changing in the future. Soldiers have been following him. Fortunately, Tang Gaozu got help from Qin Qiong and repelled these killers.

After being defeated, he chose to rest. At this moment, Dan Xiong Xin's brother Shan Xiongzhong rode. Tang Gaozu thought that the enemy was making a comeback, so he immediately picked up a bow and arrow and shot through Shan Xiongzhong with one arrow.

In addition, Tang Gaozu was ordered to crusade against Wagang Village and arrested his relatives. Although his encirclement and suppression was framed, it was finally blamed by Dan Xiong Xin.

New enmity and old hatred, Dan Xiong Xin naturally hated Li Tang. As long as he meets the Li people, he can't wait to kill them. In the process of crusade against the king, he almost died under Dan twice.

Therefore, when both sides regard each other as enemies, no matter what Li Tang thinks, it is absolutely impossible for Dan Xiong Xin to surrender to Li Shimin, because of his stubborn and strong-willed temper, which is why Dan Xiong Xin refused to surrender to Li Tang.

In 6 18 AD, Wagangzhai and Wang were defeated in World War I, and it was for the above personal reasons that Dan turned to his former enemy Wang, and was favored by Wang's daughter and became Wang's son-in-law.

Two years later, he led the army to attack the king, and Dan led the troops to fight. Unfortunately, he was defeated and captured. Li Shimin ordered Dan Xiong Xin and other generals to be executed, leaving no one. Xu Shiqi pleaded with Li Shimin, hoping that he could spare Raodan Xiong Xin's life and avoid his death, but was rejected by Li Shimin and finally executed by Li Shimin.

At the end of Sui Dynasty, Dan Xiong Xin, as the leader of the green forest at that time, had a high position in the Jianghu. In terms of war command, due to his long years of fighting, he has a strong combat capability, and his reputation in the Jianghu is no less than that of Weichi Gong. At that time, people around Qin Wang congratulated him: "Qin Wang won Weichi Gong the day before yesterday and Dan Xiong Xin today. What a blessing!"

As we all know, he has always been thirsty for talents, and his men, Cheng and Weichi Gong have all surrendered, so they can be reused. When he came to Dan Xiong Xin and faced such a fierce soldier, why did Li Shimin insist on killing him?

I think this may be because the two families in Shan Li have had a deep hatred since their parents. If we don't kill him, he will go back to Don under the pretence. If he wants revenge on a whim, it's too late to regret it.

Then there is Li Shimin's attack on Luoyang Wang Shichong twice, and once he was almost killed by Dan Xiong Xin. Fortunately, Xu Shiqi stopped him at that time. Although Li Shimin says he doesn't mind, I'm afraid he'll hate it like a knife.

Another point is that when Li Shimin made up his mind to execute Dan Xiong Xin, only Xu Shiji interceded, but Qin Qiong, who had a close friend with him in the past, did not show up. I don't know why Cheng and other Wagangzhai veterans didn't show up at that time, but I just think that if they did, they wouldn't necessarily intercede for Dan Xiong Xin and spare him.

This should also be the reason why Li Shimin wanted to kill Dan Xiong Xin. But I think the key reason is that Li Shimin has seen through Dan Xiong Xin's personality. He thinks that Dan Xiong Xin is too much like Lu Bu. As we all know, Lu Bu is called a "slave with three surnames", while Dan Xiong Xin is not much better.

He first helped Shi Biao get rid of Zhai Rang, then Shi Biao, and then Shi Biao turned to the king after his defeat, without any guilt. He Cheng, who also surrendered to Wang, declared his participation in the war after realizing that he was not a democratic leader. After Wang was forced to surrender, Shan even dreamed of taking refuge through his relationship with Xu Shiqi.

Such behavior can only be said to be downright disloyal. Li Shimin naturally won't use such people. Even if you have superb martial arts, Dan Xiong Xin will eventually be beheaded in Luoyang.

Hello, I am very interested in this question. Next, please let me express my opinion.

1. Dan and the Li family are enemies.

Because Dan's younger brother was killed by the Li family, he was afraid of Dan's revenge, so he killed him to strengthen his strength.

2. Dan's father-in-law is an anti-king.

He is afraid that Dan Xiong Xin will come again.

3. Dan Xiong Xin almost killed Li Shimin.

When you hit the king, you will be killed by Dan. Fortunately, Weichi Gong was saved, so he ended his resentment.

Please reply if there is anything wrong or unclear. If you don't want to do it in the next "stupid opinion", please adopt it. Thank you!

Why did Li Shimin kill Dan Xiong Xin Xiong Xin (? -62 1) from Yin Ji, Cao Zhou. Brave and healthy. At the end of the Sui Dynasty, he joined the Wagang Rebel Army. General Zuo Wuhou in 6 17. In 6 18, he led the army to surrender to the king. In 620, Li Shimin led an army to surround the eastern capital. Dan Xiong Xin was stabbed in the war with Wei Chijingde and fell off his horse. The following year, Kedong Jingshi, Wang and Tang were all killed. Dan Xiong Xin, Tong Ming. The leader of the rebel army in Wagangzhai at the end of Sui Dynasty. General Wu Hu won the first place, known as the "red-haired Lingguan". A golden nail, Zaoyangyun, bravely crowned the three armies.

Why did Li Shimin kill Dan Xiong Xin, Li Shimin and Dan Xiong Xin? In Romance, it is not that Shimin refused to let Dan Xiong Xin go, but that Dan Xiong Xin refused to surrender to the Tang Dynasty. Of course, this is not the case.

I have seen the following explanations: First, Dan Xiong Xin was not very brave, and at that time, the war to unify the whole country was over (the subsequent rebellion in Liu Heita was unexpected), and the people of the world no longer needed a brave general like Dan Xiong Xin. I think this view is unconvincing. If Dan Xiong Xin is not very brave, at least he is better than Shimin himself, because he can threaten Shimin's life twice. At that time, although the war to unify the whole country was over, the war against foreigners, mainly Turks, had just begun. A cavalry general like Dan Xiong Xin always has more talents, so there is no reason to say that this is unnecessary.

Secondly, there is a view that Shimin has many cavalry generals who belong to Wagang Army, such as Qin Qiong, Cheng Zhijie, Luo Shixin and even Shigong, and Dan Xiong Xin has a high prestige among these people, because Shimin is unwilling to accept him. Because this prestige should be owned by only one commander-in-chief, so everyone can only obey one commander-in-chief, and Dan Xiong Xin's entry into Tang Jun will only bring adverse effects. This opinion is very innovative and reasonable. But the question is, will Dan Xiong Xin be such a prestigious person? The person who put forward this view is obviously influenced by The Romance, because in The Romance, Dan Xiong Xin turned out to be the leader of the greenwood, and he is indeed the "big brother" of all people. But is this a historical fact? I don't think so. These people were born in Wagang, but the original leader of Wagang was Zhai Rang, not Dan Xiong Xin. (So, after Zhai Rang was killed by Shi Biao, everyone began to alienate Shi Biao, which became the turning point of Wagang Army from prosperity to decline. The reason why Shi Biao wanted to kill Zhai Rang was really the truth in this opinion-although Zhai Rang voluntarily gave the leadership to Shi Biao, his prestige among the people was still too high, which made Shi Biao unable to feel at ease. In fact, when Shimin insisted on killing Dan Xiong Xin, he was the only one who tried to persuade him. Qin Qiong and other generals from Wagang Village did not answer. Since history books don't mind recording the achievements of the world to discourage the people, there is no reason not to record the objections of other former Wagang generals. Obviously they didn't object, so there is no record. It can be seen that the former Wagang generals actually have no close relationship with Dan Xiong Xin, and they have a lifelong friendship with him.

After denying the above two popular "explanations", my personal explanation is actually very simple: because Dan Xiong Xin threatened people's lives twice, the people refused to forgive him. We should not be influenced by the image of Shimin in romance novels, thinking that Shimin in real history is a "master" who does not hold grudges and unconditionally loves talents. Romance overemphasized the love of Shimin, and made up the story that Cheng Zhijie once hunted Shimin when he was a general of crock, and Wei Chijingde even asked Shimin to surrender to the Tang Dynasty only after he was "humiliated by his legs". In fact, all these plots have never happened in history. If this really happens, I'm afraid the first reaction of the people is to cut off their heads, not to surrender. Later, I let bygones be bygones for a scholar like Wei Zhi, but when I was a prince and a horse thief in Wei Zhi, I persuaded him to make up his mind to kill the people. I don't think there is a very specific plan. As a family member of the East Palace, it is also very common to say this sentence. )

Moreover, if the records in unofficial history's Romance of Sui and Tang Dynasties are credible, it is conceivable that Dan Xiong Xin is not only a brave man, but also a glib talker. Of course, from Dan Xiong Xin's point of view, Dan Xiong Xin's words are very heroic and natural, but from Shi Min's point of view, this nature is enough to make him cry. If Shimin feels insulted by Dan Xiong Xin, then Dan Xiong Xin almost killed him. I'm afraid this hatred is second, and the humiliation on your breath is even more fatal. If you don't kill Dan Xiong Xin, how can you get rid of the people's anger? In real history, Kong Dezhao, a scholar of Xia Guo, is said to have been dragged to the top of Surabaya Building by the world because his essays were so insulting, and was directly pushed downstairs and killed. With this "lesson from the past", what's so hard to understand that Dan Xiong Xin was beheaded on the bank of Luoshui?

What makes Li Shimin an eternal monarch? Li Shimin was a great statesman, strategist, calligrapher and poet in ancient China. He was an outstanding figure who influenced the program in China and even the world, and made great contributions to ancient China. Therefore, he is not only an emperor, but also respected by people. 1. Li Shimin led troops to the world in his early years and made great contributions to the reunification of the Tang Dynasty. Second, Li Shimin is a model of an enlightened monarch. He does not stick to one pattern and uses his talents arbitrarily. He is open-minded and can realize the legal and political policy of putting human life first and not forgiving killing. Third, Li Shimin thrived in China, attached importance to irrigation and water conservancy, and developed its commercial economy, which enabled the people to recuperate and all ethnic groups to live in harmony, showing a prosperous scene of peace and prosperity. Fourth, Li Shimin, with the exception of Koguryo War, has achieved brilliant military victories. In the military history of China, there are also many examples of wars in the Tang Dynasty. 5. Li Shimin focused on the overall situation and achieved brilliant success in its domestic and foreign policies. Six, Li Shimin's calligraphy and rich writing, personal accomplishment and talent are extremely high, and he is also quite famous in calligraphy and writing. With his strong encouragement and support, calligraphy, literature and art in the Tang Dynasty all flourished. Seven, Li Shimin initiated the famous "Zhenguan Rule", which laid an important foundation for the prosperous era of Kaiyuan in the prosperous Tang Dynasty.

Why did Li Shimin kill two families of Dan Xiong Xin? It cannot be used by me. This is a threat. Of course, threats are not allowed.

Li Shimin is a wise king. Why did he kill Dan Xiong Xin with his narrow mind? Jia jialou 36 became sworn brothers, and finally each became a teacher and met each other! A large part of Li Shimin, the king of Qin, was protected, and Dan Xiong Xin was finally arrested for family feud and constant struggle with the Tang Dynasty. It was a battle doomed to failure from the beginning, but Dan Xiong Xin didn't give up fighting because of it. Many brothers were sitting beside him when he was killed. Few people can kneel down and beg the king of Qin not to kill this former Jianghu elder brother. When Qin Qiong came back, he had been killed.

I doubt that Qin Qiong's absence does not rule out the possibility that this person deliberately avoided it. He is just a little better than other so-called heroes: deliberately not being there, causing the illusion of his innocence. If he had been there, he wouldn't have knelt down to plead.

Dan Xiong Xin has a dense green forest and likes to make friends. I didn't see him do anything aboveboard before he was pursued by the king. What he did was rob the rich and help the poor. He makes friends with three mountains and five mountains, is charitable, helps the poor and has a heart-to-heart relationship with friends. He is definitely a man.

Some people commented that it's a pity that Dan knew that the king was not a wise master for his brother's manslaughter, but he refused to abandon the darkness and cast a light for himself. He was too concerned about family feuds and missed himself, and his mind was not open enough. Finally, he committed suicide sadly!

There is a saying: the so-called democratic leader and the like are all nonsense, but the interests are the same. It may be a just choice, but it is also a choice of interest.

In other words, it is the perfect combination of justice and interests. But men may choose pure love. The regime can kill you by mistake and betray you for profit, but your life will not. Moreover, the "Lord" can change and choose, but you can't choose in life. That's why Dan Xiong Xin can't "follow the historical trend" and leave us a legacy. This legacy has no sadness, only tragic, hidden in the heart, unspeakable. His loyalty to his friends is worth emulating!

Why didn't Dan Xiong Xin help Li Shimin? Tang Gaozu met a robber and shot an arrow at Dan Xiong Xin's eldest brother.