Why does the central axis of the Forbidden City deviate?

The central axis of Beijing is an extremely rare axis of architectural art in the history of world cities. However, after measurement, it is found that this line is not due south and north, but deviates from the meridian. If so, wouldn't the thrones of 33 emperors in Yuan, Ming and Qing Dynasties be crooked? Why does the central axis deviate from the meridian? Did the ancients do it on purpose? Or is there something wrong with the measurement?

When it comes to Beijing's architectural planning, many people may think of the central axis, which is one of the most important architectural features. The central axis of Beijing starts from Yongdingmen in the south and passes through Zhengyangmen, Forbidden City, Jingshan, Bell Tower and Drum Tower in the north, with a total length of about 7.8 kilometers. Taking the Forbidden City as the center, it became the main line connecting the north and south cities at that time, and today, this central axis still plays a key role. This central axis is not a concrete "line", but relatively abstract, because there are some very unique architectural forms on it, so that we can see the traces in it, just like the beating music shown because of ups and downs.

Many cities in our country have a central axis, which often coincides with the meridian. Meridian is what we usually call the meridian connecting the north and south poles. A stone rat and a stone horse were dug up in a building in Beijing in the 1950s. These two isolated cultural relics are located in two different places on the central axis. In the ancient heavenly stems and earthly branches of China, the son was a mouse and the noon was a horse, suggesting that the central axis was actually the meridian of the city.

As the imperial city, 33 emperors in Yuan, Ming and Qing Dynasties all proclaimed themselves emperors in the north and south. However, after a very careful study, an old gentleman found that the central axis and meridian were not exactly the same. From this point of view, it is possible that the thrones of 33 emperors are inclined, and Beijing is not due south and north. So, does his theory make sense? Is that really the case?

Be surprised to find that

Kui Zhongyu, a researcher at China Academy of Surveying and Mapping, has lived in Beijing for decades. Because I have been engaged in aerial remote sensing photography and mapping maps, I have a strong interest in ground objects. Once, he wanted to take a panoramic bird's eye view of Beijing. He first discovered an aerial photograph, which is a top view of the aerial photograph after processing and mosaic. In the face of high-definition images, Zhongyu Kun began to consider where to start shooting. At this time, he began to pay attention to the central axis of Beijing, which runs straight from north to south. Looking at it, he suddenly found that this line is not due south, but offset!

Kui Zhongyu knows that the map is strictly controlled according to geographical coordinates, so there should be no problem. He immediately found the satellite image of Beijing. On the satellite map, the central axis also deviates from the meridian. He bought many versions of Beijing maps, including traffic and sightseeing maps of Beijing. At first glance, the results are a little biased, and the counterclockwise direction is a little biased. This proves that this line does have an angle with the meridian.

The deviation of the central axis is a problem worth pondering. When was this north-south central axis of Beijing formed and when did it deviate?

When the ancients built a city, they should build a "central platform" as the geometric center of the city. From the Western Zhou Dynasty to the Liao and Jin Dynasties, the center and axis of the city kept drifting. It was not until the Mongolian fighters swept the square in the Yuan Dynasty that Beijing really became the political center of the country.

At that time, the center of the city was determined in the current location of the Drum Tower. After the center point is established, the central axis of the city and the position of the city are naturally established. Since then, the central axis has not changed for 800 years. Mr. Liang Sicheng once said, "Beijing's unique grand order is produced by the establishment of this central axis." The above facts show that the deviation of Beijing's central axis from the meridian was formed when the city was built in the Yuan Dynasty. In other words, the central axis deviated from the time when the Yuan Dynasty was established.

Kui Zhongyu thought, since it is found that the central axis of Beijing has a certain deviation from the map, what is this angle? So Zhong-yu Kui decided to make a field survey of Yongdingmen.

Immediately measure the axis

To determine the meridian of Yongdingmen, it is very important to know the exact time when the sun passes through Yongdingmen. Together with experts, Zhong Yu Kui calculated the noon time when the sun passed through Yongdingmen according to the world time difference, local time difference, time difference of the day and other factors.

One day in the winter of 2004, Zhong-yu Kui and surveying and mapping experts started real-time experiments at Yonglu Road facing north under Yongdingmen Gate. They erected a 2-meter-long pole in the middle of Yonglu Road. Under the telephone pole, the center line of Yan Yong Road is northward, and a 6-meter-long black tape is attached to indicate the central axis. When the sun passes through the Yongdingmen meridian, the shadow of the pole is the Yongdingmen meridian. The angle between shadow and black tape is the angle between meridian and central axis.

After accurate measurement and calculation, it is found that the central axis of Beijing deviates from the meridian by more than 2 degrees. Is this deflection angle calculated correctly? Kui Zhongyu also selected three points on the topographic map, namely Yongdingmen, Bell Tower and Di 'anmen, and calculated the deflection angle as 2 degrees and more than ten minutes, which proved that the real-time rough survey result of Yongdingmen was correct. According to this calculation, the central axis from Yongdingmen to the bell tower deviates from the meridian by 300 meters.

Is it a calculation error?

But why is the central axis of Beijing off? When the Yuan Dynasty Metropolis was built, was it deliberately biased, or was it caused by survey errors?

Longitude, latitude and azimuth all over the earth change with time. For example, there will be small periodic swings, movements and deflections during the earth's operation, which are called polar shift, nutation and precession in astronomy. So does the deviation of the central axis have anything to do with these astronomical phenomena? Kui Zhongyu specially consulted Mr. Xi, an academician of the Chinese Academy of Sciences. Xi is an astronomer and historian with an international reputation. After learning about the deviation of Beijing's central axis, he thought it inappropriate to link some astronomical phenomena with the deviation of Beijing's central axis.

Because the pole shift is a little movement in the earth's rotation, the area is very small. Although precession and nutation will affect the latitude and longitude of the star position, they will not affect the latitude and longitude of the ground, so we can rule out the factors that the celestial phenomena affect the deviation of the central axis.

So is it caused by calculation error? In ancient China, accurate measurements were made very early. Scholars in the Tang Dynasty once measured the meridian accurately in Henan. We can clearly see the straight central axis of the city from the model of the imperial city in Song Dynasty restored by Henan archaeology. Astronomy, calendar, mathematics and other aspects in ancient China reached a fairly high level, so the deviation of the central axis should not be a measurement error. It's not a technical reason. What is it?

What is the distance?

In order to uncover the mystery hidden behind the central axis, Kui Zhongyu temporarily abandoned the way of looking for reasons based on natural and technical routes and began to look for humanistic clues.

Kui Zhongyu's consideration of the trend of many ancient buildings has a certain relationship with some distant features. Does the central axis of Beijing also have a certain relationship with distant buildings? Now Beijing was built on the basis of the Yuan Dynasty, which was built by Kublai Khan. Will Kublai Khan build buildings related to Beijing in other places before?

Kui Zhongyu found several topographic maps from Beijing to Inner Mongolia. When he connected nine topographic maps, a place he had never paid attention to appeared. He was surprised to find that the central axis of Beijing extended northward, and its extension line pointed to Gukaiping, the birthplace of Kublai Khan in Yuan Shizu.

1206, Genghis Khan established the Mongolian Empire. Twenty years later, Kublai Khan designed a city, built a palace and built Kaiping, the capital of the Yuan Dynasty, in Liu.

Yuandu is closely related to Yuandu. At that time, the capital system of the Yuan Dynasty was dualistic, that is, a country had two capitals. So does this central axis of Beijing have anything to do with the capital of the Yuan Dynasty? There are always errors in the measurements on the map. In order to obtain more accurate results, it is necessary to use GPS global positioning system for more accurate mathematical calculation and field measurement. Kui Zhongyu decided to follow the central axis issued by Beijing and personally visit Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region.

Pursuing the past and exploring the present capital of Yuan Dynasty

The distance from Beijing and Hebei to Zhenglan Banner in Inner Mongolia is 270 kilometers. Kui Zhongyu thought, would the person in charge of design at that time adopt the Shangdu-Dadu line as the baseline of the central axis of the metropolis according to the wishes of the rulers at that time, so as to reflect the unity of the two capitals? With this question, accompanied by Sain, deputy director of the local cultural bureau, and Dong Xige, a historical researcher in Yuanshangdu, Kui Zhongyu went to the ruins in Yuanshangdu. The Yuanshangdu site is located in the northeast of Shangdu Town, Zhenglan Banner, Xilin Gol League, Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region.

After hundreds of years of changes, the ruins of Shangdu in the Yuan Dynasty have long been in ruins. Kui Zhongyu walks in the ancient city of Shangdu. They are looking for a route extending from the ancient capital Beijing. They unfolded the map, looked for the central axis extending from Beijing in the ruins of Shangdu in Yuan Dynasty according to the GPS satellite locator, and matched it with the map. However, where is this invisible line?

[color=Red] When Zhong-yu Kui's GPS shows east longitude 1 16 degrees 12 minutes, he knows that the distance from the point that really passes through the central axis is only 1 minute, that is, hundreds of meters. [/color] Zhong-yu Kui called this line connecting Yuandadu and Yuandu the "Two Beijing Lines". In this way, the central axis of Beijing is located at the southern end of the two capital lines. Scholars believe that modern people's accurate measurement methods should not be used to judge ancient people's measurement, because after all, at that time, they did not have such complete tools, and there is no need to accurately describe this central axis to four decimal places.

For Kui Zhongyu and many scientists, whether the reason for the deviation of the central axis is really determined by human factors needs further study, but no matter what the answer is, many cultural and historical relics on the central axis that have experienced hundreds of years of wind, frost, rain and snow will be destined to help people uncover this legendary mystery.