This victory is real.
Everyone's doubts about this great victory mainly lie in two places.
1. The triumph of Zhuxian Town is only recorded in History of Song Dynasty (volume 365) and Biography of Yue Fei (volume 365), but not in the most detailed Nandu Incident (volume 300-300) and volume 2000-2000.
Two or five hundred people hit each other, and one hundred thousand people are too exaggerated and incredible.
Two points are explained in detail below.
Recorded the history of Xu Huixin, Song Huizong, Zhao Huan, Song Qinzong, Zhao Gou and Song Gaozong. A book was written in the fifth year of Zong Shaoxi. Author Xu, born in the first year of Jingkang, was a scholar in Shaoxing in twenty-four years. I don't know when it started, but he compiled Three Dynasties North Alliance, Learn from others, and Learn from others.
It records the 36-year history of the Gaozong Dynasty from the first year of Jian 'an to the thirty-second year of Shaoxing. Author Li Xinchuan was born in Song Xiaozong Road for two years. In the first year of Qingyuan, the provincial examination failed. From then on, he never wanted to take the exam again, so he wrote a book with peace of mind. He is the author of Compilation of the Annals of the Northern League of Three Dynasties, Chronicle of Yanbu since its establishment and Compilation of Annals. In his later years, 23 friends, including Yi Xu and Wei Liaoweng, recommended him as a collating history museum, specializing in reciting poems and editing Li. After writing, I took the position of assistant minister of the Ministry of Industry and said, "After that, I lived in Fengci Temple in Chaozhou and devoted myself to the compilation of the four Dynasties of Zhongxing."
It is not difficult to see that, compared with the official large-scale revision of the history of the Thirteen Dynasties, the records of the years and the history of the Song Dynasty since the establishment of Emperor Yan are only private revisions of history.
Or some people say that the record of Yue Fei's attack on Zhuxian Town in "Three Dynasties North Alliance" is mainly based on York's "Records of Jian Yan Years".
History of Song Dynasty, Edited by Jin Tuo and Edited by Three Dynasties and North Alliance are all private historical works, so their credibility should be discounted. However, York is the grandson of Yue Fei, and the recorded year was not seen until the establishment of Yan in the battle of Zhuxian Town, but neither Jintuo _ Bian nor Jintuo _ Bian has a year, so the year record of the Three Dynasties North Alliance Association is suspicious.
However, Yi Xu, a friend of Li Xinchuan, said in his notes: "Focus on Jin Tuo _ Compilation and Jian Yan Zhi, and then catch up with the world and lose the old news. The trustworthy can be taken, the suspicious can be cut, and the suspicious can learn. After collecting opinions, it can be sorted out for a long time. That is to say, The Calendar is actually a work based on the official history Yao Hui and Records of Jian Yan Years edited by Qin Gui and Qin Cong, combined with hearsay in rural areas.
It is outrageous that Qin Gui and his son tampered with the official history, so that they were deleted. According to historical records, "whoever talks about people's chapters and knows their self-discipline is called' this old Qin pen is also'"
The History Palace in the Southern Song Dynasty once boldly played Shaoxing for thirty-three years, saying, "From the first year of Yan Kaiguo to the twelfth year of Shaoxing, the calendar reached 590 volumes, with many mistakes."
Li Xinchuan also knows that there are problems with books such as "The Emperor's Calendar", so he specifically stated in his works: "Press: Now Zhongxing Yao Hui is the historical research institute, and Qin Ni's secretary is the junior supervisor, trying to beg for deletion. You can't believe all your doubts. Attached to it, it is more important to point to the cloud. "
Therefore, there is no need to believe too much in the myth of the emperor's calendar, especially in major events involving Yue Fei's meritorious deeds.
0755-7900365 Calendar: "Fly into Zhuxian Town, forty-five miles away from Bianjing, engage in war with Wu Shu, and send warriors to ride on their backs 500 times. After the big break, Wu Shu fled back to Bianjing. "
In addition to the record since the year of Chuangyan, from the words "drums will enter the capital of Beijing"
In the Biography of Yue Fei, Volume 77 of History of Song Dynasty, it was recorded that after Yue Fei was recalled by the Twelve Kings, "Zong Bi sent Kong Yanzhou to Bianzhou and Zhengzhou", that is, Wu Shu took advantage of Yue Fei's displacement and sent Kong Yanzhou to occupy Bianjing again.
This fully proves that Yue Fei first defeated Wu Shu in Zhuxian Town, and then sent troops to recapture Bianjing, the old capital of the Northern Song Dynasty. Just because Song Gaozong used letters to urge him to return to Li, 8 jin j, that is, Border 2, added some points and reoccupied Bianjing.
Therefore, there is no doubt that the triumph of Zhuxian Town exists.
As for the record of "500 brave men defeated each other by 100 thousand troops", don't argue about the possibility in such a hurry, just look at various history books.
For example, from 0755 to 79000 years ago, Liu Yu led dozens of people out for reconnaissance and accidentally met thousands of people from the rebel Sun Enjun. Emperor Wu of Song: "If it happens, all the generals will die and the rest will go ashore." When the thief approached the shore, Yu Fen killed several people with a long knife, but he had to go ashore, and he still shouted at them. The thief left and I killed many people. "
You see, in the case of "followers are all dead", Emperor Wu of song chased down thousands of people by himself. Do you believe it or not?
This matter, the letter is true; If you don't believe it, it's fake.
In addition, Bian Nian wrote to General Zuo and ordered General Xue Shixiong to keep 30,000 troops in Qilijing. Dou Jiande's 280 warriors "broke through their camp and attacked them, and all the heroes in the world were in chaos, and they all made a dash for the door." This is the record of 280 people defeating 30 thousand people. Do you believe it or not?
The story of Wang Junkuo, a tile hero in 2000, is equally astounding: after joining, he was appointed as the magistrate of Zhuzhou, and the pseudo-prefect of Hanoi and Changshan County. Tang Gaozu Li Yuan once sent a letter of commendation saying, "You beat a thousand thieves with thirteen men. Since ancient times, it's nothing that you beat the crowd with fewer! "
Boy, with thirteen men, the enemy will exceed ten thousand. Then Yue Fei broke 100,000 with 500 people. Still too much?
Okay, no kidding.
Seriously, the so-called "500 people on the other side defeated 100,000 people" is actually not that one person attacked 200 people on the other side, but that 500 people attacked a place on the other side together, which was turbulent and the whole army was shocked and collapsed.
Think about it. Didn't Jin Jun defeat the million-strong army of the former Qin Dynasty with only 80,000 men in the Battle of Feishui?
The so-called frightened bird, the imaginary string can be lowered.
After several large-scale attacks in Yancheng and Yingchang, Jin Jun actually lost his fighting spirit and wanted to break up. Yue Jiajun arrived, struggled a few times, shot and quickly retreated. Is that weird? This is not surprising.
Yue Fei, a hero of the Song Dynasty and a warrior of China, deserves our future generations' admiration.