Objection: Guan Yu should not put Cao Cao in Huarong Road.
If there is a "Huarong Road" across the street, saying that I will not release him in Huarong Road, I will take Cao Cao back and ask him to sign some exemption agreement before releasing him. Then how should we refute it?
It turns out that people who say Guan Yu shouldn't let Cao Cao go are wise after the event. Has Guan Yu read The Romance of the Three Kingdoms? Can he know the consequences of letting Cao Cao go? Chen Geng, the founding general, saved Chiang Kai-shek before. Afterwards, Chen Geng said, don't save Chiang Kai-shek. As for what agreement to sign, it is even more useless. The Soviet Union also signed a peace agreement with Germany. The Soviet Union paralyzed itself because of this peace agreement, resulting in tens of thousands of people dying in vain at the beginning of the war. Without this agreement, it will be wary of Germany, and the casualties will be much less.
Whatever the military orders are, give Cao Cao what he should kill. But it only borrowed the reason why he was favored by Cao Cao.
Then, I guess the other party should be entangled in some details. This is inconsistent with Zhuge Liang's right strategy in Longzhong. Even if Cao Cao dies, it doesn't mean that Cao Pi is incompetent: once the northern crisis is lifted, the alliance between Liu Bei and Sun Quan will directly fall apart, not to mention that the north has long been unified. It makes sense to give you three central arguments:
1: At that time, it was the forces that the Northern Group tried to deal with that killed Cao Cao?
At that time, Sun Quan had just joined forces with Northern France to destroy Liu Bei first. If someone from Sun Quan's side killed Cao Cao, Zhuge Liang must have seen something about Guan Yu: Guan Yu's yearning. If he doesn't miss his feelings, he is not Guan Yu, and he is not a soldier. Very controversial. Liu Bei must help deal with Sun Quan. Who was the first bird?
The positive side is very powerful, and I also support it, and it is in line with history.
If Cao Cao is not allowed to go, the weak Liu Bei Group will soon be destroyed by Sun Wu, and the world is estimated to be bamboo slips.
Who would do such a stupid thing as making a wedding dress for someone else?
After Guan Yu released Cao Cao in Huarong Road, the consequence was chaos and war.
After Battle of Red Cliffs, a tripartite confrontation was formed. Cao Cao's escape in Huarong Road maintained the unity of the northern regime. Imagine that if Cao Cao died in Huarong Road, the north would fall into chaos again. The general trend in the world is dominated by Sun Liu, with constant enemy and enemy situations and constant wars. The three countries are strong and dare not make friends with each other. Conducive to the stability and development of production in various countries. Interpreting Cao Cao's righteousness is not only a small personal righteousness, but also the great righteousness of the world.
Yi Dao of Huarong Road explained Cao Cao: Why did Guan Yu let Cao Cao go? Guan Yu Huarong released Cao Cao. Unofficial history recorded that Cao Cao's kindness to Guan Yu was deliberately designed by Zhuge Liang. No matter which legend it is, it is a matter of romance, not historical facts.
Viewpoint 1:
Guan Yu's release of Cao Cao is an inevitable result. Zhuge Liang had long expected that Guan Yu would release Cao Cao and deliberately let Guan Yu make a military order. This matter has the following necessities and benefits for Zhuge Liang.
First, Cao Cao was released out of consideration for the overall situation of the world at that time. After Battle of Red Cliffs released Cao Cao, who was badly hurt by the original gas, he could use it to effectively contain Wu Dong and leave enough time for Liu Bei's development. If Cao Cao was killed, Sun Quan's military strength in the world at that time was unparalleled. If Cao Cao is destroyed, Liu Bei will be the next one to be destroyed. Therefore, from a military point of view, it must be released.
Second, Guan Yu was saved by Cao Cao for not killing him, which was a great favor to him. In the future, Guan Yu will not look back and forth when fighting Cao Cao. From the human point of view, it is bound to be released.
Third, it was Zhuge Liang's original intention to let Guan Yu make a written pledge to fulfill a military order. First, only in this way can Guan Yu risk his life to let Cao Cao go, so that human feelings can be completely returned; Second, Zhuge Liang assisted Liu Bei and Liu Bei's two brothers. Of course, they would not listen to him. Through this written pledge to fulfill a military order, Guan Yu's pigtails will be in Zhuge Liang's hands in the future, and it really happens. Since then, Guan Yu has bowed to Zhuge Liang, and Guan Yu has always been like this. Zhang Fei naturally has no more words, so Zhuge Liang has become the second person below Liu Bei and above everyone else.
Viewpoint 2:
Because Cao Cao is not only kind to Guan Yu, but also interested in what Guan Yu wants and gives, the most important thing is to promise Guan Yu to let him go as long as he finds Liu Bei, so Guan Yu pays him back.
In troubled times, in the face of power struggle and life and death, all agreements are waste paper. Take the recent cooperation between China and the United States as an example. Finally, in order to compete for sovereignty, it is not that we fight and sometimes sign agreements to avoid war, nor is it because everyone believes in each other, but that both sides are unable to do their best and cannot find their own steps. In real history, the supreme leader of the enemy, like Cao Cao,