Martial arts reviews in the Three Kingdoms reflect everyone's preferences and aesthetic standards, so there is no need to deliberately unify the thoughts of netizens. But it is precisely for this reason that the power ranking gives everyone the feeling that it is not rigorous and noisy. One reason why China lags behind the world in modern science and technology is that it despises mathematics. This is also reflected in many netizens' comments on the Three Kingdoms-they have written thousands of words of military comments, but they can't come up with any comparable data, so the result is bound to be random.
Some netizens counted all the one-on-one hits in the romance, which is a rigorous embodiment, but at the beginning of the ranking, they had to be doped with personal subjective elements. This is also the embodiment of the charm of the ranking of the three countries' forces-everyone makes sense and no one makes sense. Even the most famous "One Lu, Two Zhao, Three Dian Wei ..." exists in one version or another, and the ranking will change with the times and people's aesthetic standards.
In order to give you a relatively satisfactory ranking, this ranking will try to avoid some problems that are easy to introduce any subjective elements. Specifically, it is not limited to the comparison of the number of rounds; Don't guess the effectiveness of the battle; Nor does it discuss whether it is completely surrounded or semi-surrounded, one by one or together; Don't guess what is the first sound, the first cheat, the age and the state; Let alone discuss whether the defeat is true or false, whether it is insufficient strength or failure to foresee the enemy, or whether it is a strategic need; Wait a minute. These issues have caused controversy in various forums, and no unified conclusion can be reached, so they are avoided.
The statistical parameters are war, capture, killing, injury, injury, killing, capture, capture and killing rate-capture and killing rate, killing rate-killing rate. Based on the well-known Mao Ben of Romance of the Three Kingdoms (Mao Ben and Robben draw the same conclusion because they avoid subjective problems, because the results of these two versions are basically the same, but there are differences in description techniques and rounds), this paper makes objective statistics and draws some conclusions with little difference.
What is one-on-one hit and what is strict one-on-one hit? Some netizens say that romantic C.P357 is a one-on-one hit, but many examples in it are obviously not one-on-one. When it comes to the strictest one-on-one fight, that is, the one with no soldiers and no hidden weapons and bows and arrows, there are not many games in romance. Because the concept of one-on-one hit is not unified, it is bound to be subjective to count the number of one-on-one hits in romantic films. For this reason, when making statistics below, it is not the number of one-on-one hits, but the number of opponents. War refers to the attack between famous generals in legendary stories. In the romance, Lu Bu and 17 opponents crossed head-on, which was recorded as the battle of 17. In this way, the question of how many times Zhang Fei and Lu Bu fought was avoided.
So is Ma Dai's attack on Wei Yan an example of war? If it is up to you, most netizens will feel uncomfortable. But if you don't count, I'm afraid those controversial examples of fast horses, cold arrows and sneak attacks are not clear. The force of the military commanders of the Three Kingdoms is mythical, and they can fight dozens or hundreds of rounds, and they can kill without injury among thousands of troops. Subjectively speaking, they should not be unresponsive to attacks from behind and from the side. Therefore, a criterion is adopted to define that confrontation in all situations except sleeping and being tied is an effective example of war. In this way, there will be no dispute statistically, although there are some problems with the standard.
A further definition is: if you catch a general with a name, if you catch him personally with soldiers and other military commanders, you will also admit that it is effective, otherwise there will be many problems in statistics. But the examples captured by soldiers don't count. There is not much difference between killing and injuring. Cases that emphasize post-war death are also classified as homicides here, and the casualties of soldiers and unknown military commanders are not counted.
The capture, killing and injury between two military commanders are only counted once. If Sun Ce's capture in Miami leads to his death at the same time, it will only be counted in Miami. Huang Zhong once captured and wounded Xia Houshang respectively, and only captured statistics. Catch > kill > hurt, only take the big one. Fortunately, there are no two military commanders in the romance. This time, you captured or hurt me, and next time, I will be arrested. Br> The number of situations of draw and ordinary defeat (neither death nor injury) is not specifically analyzed, because some controversial issues will be involved.
Finally, it is emphasized that only the monarchs of the three countries and the military commanders who have more than four opponents are counted. We can only apologize to Gao Lan and Cao Ren, whose opponents are no more than three.
Reply on August 7, 2006 17: 34
Cai qimin
0 vermicelli
second floor
The statistical results are as follows:
First, there are 40 famous players who have fought against Zhao Yun. Followed by: (2) Guan Yu 27, (3) Zhang Fei 24, (4) Chu Xu 22, (5) Lu Bu 17, (6) Ma Chao 16, (7) Zhang Liao 13, (8) Wei Yan/kloc.
Comment: This result also reflects the popularity of military commanders to some extent. Zhao Yun and Guan Yu have the most appearances and are the most popular star actors. No wonder they have many supporters.
Subjectively speaking, the military commanders who fought side by side with Chu Xu have the highest comprehensive quality. The name "Lu Bu Zhao Yunma Juck Zhang Fei Dian Wei Guan Yu Pound Zhou Tai Huang Xu" is enough to make other military commanders feel ashamed. The quality of Lu Bu's opponent list "Zhang Fei, Dian Wei, Chu Xu, Guan Yu, Xia Houdun and Xia" is also good, but it is estimated that it can only rank third, which is worse than Zhang Fei's opponent list "Lu Bu Ma Chao, Chu Xu, Zhang Liao, Zhang Ren, Zhang He and Huang Xuxia". Guan Yu and Ma Chao's opponent list can be ranked fourth and fifth respectively, and it will be even worse if they go down.
Comment: In the past, Chu Xu was somewhat underestimated. Now that the opponent list comes out, I feel that the tiger idiot really deserves its reputation. I have fought with some of the most famous military commanders. As a military commander, I won't feel any regrets.
The ranking of the number of captured and killed military commanders (captured can be killed, captured is better than killed, but setting its weight is bound to involve subjectivity, so the captured and killed are treated equally for the time being) is: (1) Zhao Yun26, (2) Guan Yu 17, (3) Zhang Fei 12, (4) Chu Xu7.
Comments: Gan Ning can enter the fourth place, which is really beyond my expectation. However, Lu Bu lost the election, which is estimated to be beyond the expectation of many netizens.
The ranking of the quality of the four captured and killed military commanders: subjective (subjective is emphasized because no one can prove that Fang Yue, Mu Shun and Wu Anguo are not as good as Yan Liang, Wen Chou and Hua Xiong), and "Yan Liangwen demonizes Hua Xiong" in Guan Yu's list of ghosts and talents is undoubtedly familiar to everyone, ranking first; The "Huang Guanyu Bell" in Ma Zhong's murder list is believed to make many new netizens shine at the moment and can be tied for the first place; Zhao Yun, the murderer, also has several tough guy murders, and the third place is scheduled; The rest, such as killing Zhang Liao, Huang Zhong killing Xia, Shamoko killing Gan Ning, Zhou Tai killing Shamoko and so on. , are of good quality; It's not easy to row.
Comment: Ma Dai is the most lethal in romance. Ma Dai captured and killed four ethnic minorities. He was the younger brother of Ma Chao, the god of A Qiang, and an expert in foreign wars.
The ranking of the oilseed coefficient (capture rate-capture rate+kill rate-kill rate) of the Five Soldiers is: (1) Sun Ce 0.83, (2) Ma Dai 0.75, (3) Zhao Yun 0.70, Gan Ning 0.70, (5) Guan Xing 0.67, and.
Comment: Sun Ce deserves to be the overlord. Except Taishi Ci, all his opponents were captured and killed by him. Ma Dai is a well-deserved veteran activist. He is too speculative. Two children, Guan Xing and Zhang Bao, actually joined the ranks of soldiers. I don't know, Wei Yan is also very oily.
Six other people
The most famous military commanders were Cao Cao and Guan Yu, both of whom were injured three times. It seems that if you want to be a "public official", you must suffer more injuries.
The number of captured enemies is the highest in Ma Dai, with five; Zhaoyun second, there are three; Xia Houdun ranks third, with two; There are less than two left.
Among the military commanders, Cao Cao -0.5 is the lowest, followed by Taishi Ci 0, Zhu Rong 0, Wen Chou 0, Yu Ban 0 and Dian Wei 0. 1 1 is also very low.
Among the monarchs of the Three Kingdoms, Liu Bei performed well, killing 1, wounding 1, and defeating Lu Bu. He was second only to Sun Ce in the comprehensive performance of monarchs, and definitely ranked first among military commanders. Although he is a little worse than the performance in the Three Kingdoms, he deserves to be the second largest hero in the world. Cao Cao became a wounded king, but he killed 1 military commanders and tried to assassinate them. His performance was not bad. It is a pity that Sun Quan did not show any combat performance.
Seven-level troops (subjective)
In the most rigorous one-on-one fight excluding hidden weapons and horses, fifteen people not only performed well, but also failed without any defeat. I divide them into five levels, and the reason why each level is together is based on the romance and birds of a feather flock together. The difference in the value of the same level of force depends on fame and public opinion, and it is no longer possible to distinguish between high and low according to the details provided by love.
The first floor: Lu Bu (100) Zhao Yun (99) "The technology is the most comprehensive and stable, with the least mistakes and flaws. 』
The second floor: Ma Chao (99), Zhang Fei (99), Chu Xu (98) and Dian Wei (98). 』
The third layer: Guan Yu (98), Huang Zhong (97) and Pound (97), "Huang Guan and Guan Pang fought. 』
The fourth floor: Taishi Ci (97), Sun Ce (97), Zhang Liao (96), Gan Ning (96), "Sun Tai and Taizhang fought, Wei had Zhang Liao, and he was lonely and prosperous".
The fifth floor: Yan Liang (96) Wen Chou (95) "Yan is famous, and he is good at both. 』
The queue is:
Lu Bu, (Zhao Yun, Ma Chao, Zhang Fei), (Chu Xu, Dian Wei, Guan Yu), (Huang Zhong, Pound, Taishi Ci, Sun Ce), (Zhang Liao, Gan Ning, Yan Liang), Wen Chou